“It is not the answer that enlightens, but the question.”
— Eugène Ionesco, playwright

Chasing Influence: Transformational Coaching to Build Champions for Life and What’s Your Juice? Unlock the Energy that Transforms Performance, Fuels Purpose, and Ignites the People Around You are available on Amazon and Audible!
The Question Was the Answer
One of my best friends is a very successful college football coach, and recently I had the opportunity to sit in on his team’s pregame meeting.
The day before the game, the meeting room looked the way you’d expect. Tiered rows of padded seats, a big screen up front, and a room full of players in team gear. The staff—and players—had spent the week buried in film and game plans.
I’d seen plenty of pregame meetings before. Usually it’s a coach with a clicker and a week’s worth of installs, unloading all of it in half an hour at the pace of an auctioneer. Players nod, a little of it sticks, and the rest washes over them.
Instead of that scene playing out again, this coach walked to the front of the room and asked a question. “What play do you like in this situation?”
Hands didn’t creep up. Answers flowed, one after another, from all over the room. Then he asked another question, and another, quick enough that nobody had time to drift. They locked in. Players advocated for their favorite calls. Someone called his own number for a play and got the whole room laughing, and the next answer came right on top of the laugh. Every player in that room looked ready to be called on, because any of them might be.
Then he asked the room, “What have you heard a teammate say that you didn’t know?”
I’m a sports fan. I can follow the general shape of a game plan, but most of the language in that room went over my head. Formations, fronts, coverages, and checks are their own dialect. It didn’t matter. I didn’t need to understand the scheme to see what was happening. For thirty minutes, the players did the teaching, and a lot of what they taught was each other.
They were underdogs going into that game. You’d never have known it in that room. It was awake and loud and fun, and by the end you could feel how sure they were of what they knew. I’ve sat in the other kind of pregame, too, the kind that drains the room a little more with every slide. This room was dialed in.
Educators have a name for the old way: the sage on the stage. Most of us have coached or led that way without thinking about it. We’ve worked hard to learn what we know, and we’re eager to hand it over. The pregame talk, the halftime speech, and the Monday staff meeting turn into the moments we talk the most. It feels responsible, as if every extra minute of us talking makes them a little more prepared.
There’s a reason it feels that way. In a 2006 study at Washington University in St. Louis, psychologists had students read short passages and then either read them again or try to recall what they’d read. Five minutes later, the students who reread did better. A week later, the ones who’d had to pull it out of their own heads remembered more.
That’s what I watched happen in that room. When a player answers a question in front of his teammates, he finds out he knows it, and so does everyone listening. When he names something he learned from the guy next to him, that teammate hears it too. The confidence in that room didn’t come from a speech about belief. It came from a whole team hearing each other get it right.
This spring, before we walk through bunt coverage for the fortieth time, I want to ask my shortstop where the second baseman is going. I want to ask a freshman what he’s learned from our returning catcher. When our advisors and coaches sit down together later this month, we will ask them what they know rather than tell them what I know. It’s harder than it sounds. Asking means waiting through the silence, living with an answer that’s only half right, and trusting the room to fix it.
How much of what you say this week could you ask instead?
Oh, and the game the next day? The underdogs won it on the last play. I’d love to tell you the questions did that. Maybe they didn’t. But over time, I’m convinced questions like those win more games than anyone will ever know.
“When their work is done, the people say, ‘We did it ourselves.’”
— Lao Tzu
Connecting this quote to the story. Great leadership isn't about providing all the answers; it's about asking the right questions so others develop the knowledge, confidence, and ownership to succeed on their own.
This week’s Chasing Influence tip: Don't mistake your talking for their learning; give others the opportunity to teach what they know.

